Welsh Government misses a crucial moment for a wilder future in the new Agriculture (Wales) Bill

Welsh Government misses a crucial moment for a wilder future in the new Agriculture (Wales) Bill

The Welsh Government has failed to place nature restoration at the heart of the Agriculture (Wales) Bill yesterday in the Senedd, an action that could further threaten natures recovery

Welsh Government are about to introduce a new Agriculture Act; this will set out what support will be given to farmers in Wales. For many years we have been campaigning for the need to include the restoration of nature as a key outcome for farm support. Many farmers are already making a difference for nature through environmental schemes. However, there hasn’t been sufficient financing and action at scale to stop the loss of nature in our rural landscapes. This hasn’t been the fault of farming but a lack of ambition in farming policies. Only farmers can restore nature as 90% of Wales land is farmed, so we must give the right incentivise to restore nature

The nature crisis in Wales has been recognised by Welsh Government. Any crisis needs immediate action and at scale and pace, and the nature crisis is no different. If we are to see nature flourish again for future generations to enjoy, we need the right scale of farm support. The State of Nature Report 2019 highlighted nature’s decline in Wales, concluding that 1 in 6 species are at risk of extinction in Wales. Continued decline in quality and quantity of natural habitats will also have detrimental effects on everything from food to clean air, so the Agriculture (Wales) Bill is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to put us on the right side of history.      

Unfortunately, Welsh Government have missed this opportunity to restore nature by not including these words on the front of the Bill. So why are words so important? Legislation is there to enable the right responses or actions to happen. If nature’s restoration was used, then future farm support would need to be targeted to achieve this. Instead, weaker words to maintain and enhance are used. This is not suitable in a crisis as it reduces the impact the Bill will have on practical action to bring nature back to our countryside.

A key part of the Agriculture (Wales) Bill is the Sustainable Farming Scheme which will come into force in April 2025 and will change the way that farmers are paid. It’s important that farming and nature are connected strongly in the Bill; after all, many species in our countryside call agricultural land their home. Farmers need to be rewarded and recognised as custodians of the countryside. They also hold the key to helping society adapt to our changing climate, from holding back flood water to storing carbon in peat bogs.

Sunsetting over peatland

Mark Hamblin/2020 VISION

Responding to the news that nature restoration will not be included in the Agriculture (Wales) Bill, Rachel Sharp, Director of Wildlife Trusts:

“There are moments throughout history that steps can be taken to have an enormous positive impact on nature, and here in Wales, this was one of them. Not seeking to restore nature will weaken this ambition, however we remain positive that we will be able to work with farmers to put nature into recovery whilst working together to ensure farmers are rewarded for their critical role”

Tim Birch, Senior Policy and Advocacy Manager for Wildlife Trusts Wales added:

“The Welsh Government has declared a nature crisis. They need to take urgent action to ensure it's recovery - not at some point in the future but now. That is why we have been urging Welsh Government to ensure that the Agriculture (Wales) Bill puts restoring nature at it's heart. We need farming to work with and restore nature. We owe it to future generations to bring back nature across Wales”.